Cosmic rays may offer an out-of-this-world answer to a long-standing mystery about lightning on Earth, a new study suggests.
“The original theory of lightning initiation was proposed in the 1960s and 1970s,” said Xuan-Min Shao, a scientist at Los Alamos National Laboratory in New Mexico and lead author of the new study, published March 3 in the journal JGR Atmospheres . “It postulated that electrons get ionized in the air and initiate what we call a thermal breakdown,” Shao told Space.com. “But that process would require a very strong electric field in the cloud, and that has never been measured.” In fact, Shao added, the strongest electric field ever detected inside storm clouds was 10 times weaker than what would be needed to spark lightning based on that theory.
To solve the long-standing puzzle, Shao and his colleagues used an array of radio antennas to record the precise progression of lightning discharges in space and time with an unprecedented accuracy and resolution. The array consists of two antenna clusters, located 7 miles (11.5 kilometers) apart at Los Alamos, which allowed the team to create a three-dimensional view of each lightning strike’s path.
The findings presented in the new study are based on observations of a single storm on July 30, 2022, that produced over 300 lightning flashes. In addition to the buildup and trajectory of the lightning bolts, the researchers measured the polarization, or direction, of the electrical current that made up the lightning and compared these two data sets.
“We compared the direction of the lightning signal propagation along several hundred meters and compared that with the direction of the polarization of the spark,” Shao said. “We found that it wasn’t aligning. It was not in the same direction as the lightning propagation. That gave us an indication that lighting spark during the first tens of microseconds is not driven by the electric field in the cloud. It must be driven by something else.”
That something else, Shao believes, is cosmic ray showers. Cosmic ray showers are cascades of high-energy particles triggered in the atmosphere by cosmic rays — bursts of charged hydrogen nuclei that zigzag across the universe at nearly the speed of light . Cosmic rays can come from distant supernovas , black holes and even the sun, and they constantly lash Earth’s upper atmosphere. When they splinter as they interact with air molecules, they produce cascades of exotic particles such as pions, muons, high-energy electrons , and their antimatter counterparts, known as positrons.
“[A] positron is what we call antimatter,” Shao said. “It’s the same as [an] electron, but it has a positive charge instead of a negative one.”
The presence of positrons in cosmic ray showers could explain the discrepancy between the direction of the lightning discharges and that of the electrical current in the spark observed by the Los Alamos array, he said.
A lightning storm over the Pacific Ocean as seen from the International Space Station at night. (Image credit: NASA)
Shao and his colleagues are not the first ones to look for a connection between lightning and cosmic rays. However, the new observations are significant because they do not align with any of the earlier theories, Shao noted.
The results are exciting, he said, but more work remains to be done. Cosmic rays batter our planet all the time, but their impacts are quite hard to detect.
“We would really like to have direct simultaneous observations of the two phenomena — lightning and cosmic ray showers,” Shao said. “But that’s going to be very difficult because the particle detectors that can detect those showers on the ground can only catch them when they are coming from a certain direction. With the current systems, we may only be able to detect about one in every thousand of them.”
For now, the researchers will attempt to replicate their measurements on a higher number of thunderstorms and lightning flashes. They will also look for possible correlations between the number of lightning strikes and the phase of the solar cycle .
Researchers think that during the most active part of the sun’s 11-year cycle, known as solar maximum , fewer cosmic rays reach the planet because its magnetic field is strengthened by the constant whipping of the solar wind . This strengthened magnetic field is better at repelling the incoming cosmic rays, which, in theory, should make the atmosphere less conducive to lightning formation. However, so far, data on this is scarce, Shao said.
“It’s a very hard problem to address because lightning rate can be affected by many other factors,” Shao said. “We would need people to collect a lot of lightning data globally to see this effect, but you have to rule out some other factors there too.”
