05:57 GMT - Tuesday, 18 March, 2025

Trendy Exercise Alternative ‘WBV’ May Be As Effective As Working Out, Study Finds

Home - Family & Relationships - Trendy Exercise Alternative ‘WBV’ May Be As Effective As Working Out, Study Finds

Share Now:


Woman standing on a whole-body vibration (WBV) plateWoman standing on a whole-body vibration (WBV) plate

(© Andres Mejia – stock.adobe.com)

In a nutshell

  • Whole-body vibration produced similar metabolic benefits to treadmill exercise in diabetic mice, improving insulin sensitivity and reducing liver fat
  • Both exercise and vibration therapy normalized muscle fiber diameter and reduced fat cell size in visceral adipose tissue
  • Vibration therapy might offer an alternative for people who can’t perform traditional exercise, though human clinical trials are still needed

AUGUSTA, Ga. — What if you could get some of the benefits of exercise without breaking a sweat or spending hours at the gym? Scientists at Augusta University have found something that sounds almost too good to be true: simply standing on a vibrating platform might help manage diabetes almost as effectively as traditional exercise.

Their research, published in the journal Endocrinology and first posted on StudyFinds in 2017, shows that whole-body vibration (WBV) created many of the same improvements in diabetic mice as running on a treadmill. These improvements included better blood sugar control, less fat in the liver, and healthier muscles.

“We’re not talking about those shaky belt machines from late-night infomercials,” you might say. And you’d be right. This is different—a carefully controlled scientific investigation using specific vibration frequencies that seem to trigger beneficial metabolic changes throughout the body.

Testing Whole-Body Vibration On Mice

The research team split their experiment between normal mice and those with a genetic mutation that causes obesity and diabetes. These “db/db” mice lack working leptin receptors, which makes them eat excessively and develop metabolic problems similar to human Type 2 diabetes.

For three months, some mice stayed sedentary (the couch potatoes of the group), some ran on treadmills for 45 minutes daily (the gym rats), and others stood on platforms that vibrated at 32 Hz with 0.5g acceleration for 20 minutes each day (the shake-and-bake group). That vibration is gentle—not enough to give you a headache, but enough to make your body continuously adjust to the movement.

What makes this study stand out is how thorough the researchers were. They didn’t just check weight and blood sugar; they examined muscle fibers under microscopes, measured fat cells, analyzed liver tissue, and even tested bone density and strength. This whole-body assessment revealed something unexpected: the mice who just stood there getting vibrated showed improvements strikingly similar to those who ran on treadmills.

Woman training on a whole-body vibration plateWoman training on a whole-body vibration plate
(© wildworx – stock.adobe.com)

Both the exercise and vibration groups lost some weight, though not dramatically. More impressively, both treatments fixed the muscle wasting that normally happens in diabetic mice. Without help, the diabetic mice developed atrophied muscles—skinnier muscle fibers that don’t work as well. But after either treadmill running or vibration therapy, their muscle fibers plumped back up to normal size.

For diabetes management, the blood sugar improvements were especially noteworthy. The sedentary diabetic mice had sky-high blood sugar and poor responses to insulin. However, both exercise and vibration therapy substantially improved how their bodies handled glucose. The treadmill runners showed the biggest improvements in glucose clearing from the bloodstream, but both treatment groups got better at responding to insulin.

Fat distribution changed too. The mice that exercised or received vibration therapy had smaller fat cells in their visceral fat—the dangerous kind that surrounds internal organs and strongly correlates with heart disease and diabetes. Their livers also contained less fat, reducing the hepatic steatosis (fatty liver) that often accompanies diabetes.

Interestingly, both treatments boosted levels of osteocalcin in the diabetic mice. Osteocalcin is a hormone produced by bone cells that affects metabolism. Though the effects on bone structure were modest, the hormone increase suggests that vibration therapy might work partly through bone-related signaling pathways.

Can WBV Replace A Workout Session At The Gym?

The research team acknowledges that traditional exercise still offers the most complete health benefits. However, whole-body vibration might provide an alternative for people who can’t exercise due to mobility issues, severe obesity, or other limitations.

“Our study is the first to show that whole-body vibration may be just as effective as exercise at combating some of the negative consequences of obesity and diabetes,” said the study’s first author, Meghan E. McGee-Lawrence in a statement. “While WBV did not fully address the defects in bone mass of the obese mice in our study, it did increase global bone formation, suggesting longer-term treatments could hold promise for preventing bone loss as well.”

Women running on treadmill, working outWomen running on treadmill, working out
Whole-body vibration may offer some of the metabolic benefits from running on a treadmill, but hitting the gym is still the best bet. (© NDABCREATIVITY – stock.adobe.com)

Hope For Diabetes Patients

The study raises fascinating questions about how mechanical forces translate into metabolic benefits. Is it the repeated muscle contractions caused by the vibration? Changes at the cellular level? Effects on circulation? The answers could lead to even more targeted treatments for metabolic disorders.

Vibration platforms have been around for years, often marketed with exaggerated fitness claims. But this research suggests they might actually have real benefits, especially for metabolic health. The key is using the right frequency and amplitude—parameters that were carefully controlled in this study but might vary in commercial products.

For the millions of people struggling with Type 2 diabetes, this research offers a new possibility. Vibration platforms are relatively affordable compared to many medical treatments, require minimal physical effort, and take little time.

But pump the brakes before you rush to buy one. This study was done in mice, not humans. While mice have similar metabolic systems to humans in many ways, we’ll need human clinical trials to confirm these benefits translate to people.

Also, the vibration therapy didn’t fix everything. The diabetic mice still had abnormal blood fats and some concerning liver markers. This suggests vibration therapy might work best as part of a more elaborate approach to managing diabetes, not as a stand-alone miracle cure. Before giving WBV a shot, you should first speak with your doctor.

Nevertheless, this study challenges how we think about exercise. Maybe it’s not just the huffing and puffing that matters, but also how mechanical forces affect our tissues and cells. In a future where doctors increasingly prescribe personalized treatments, some patients with metabolic disorders might get recommendations for specific vibration protocols alongside their other treatments—especially those who can’t do traditional workouts.

Paper Summary

Methodology

The scientists designed their experiment with meticulous planning. They worked with two types of mice: normal ones and those with a genetic mutation affecting leptin receptors (db/db mice) that made them obese and diabetic. Each type was split into three groups: those that did nothing special (sedentary), those that ran on treadmills, and those that stood on vibrating platforms. The study ran for 12 weeks, with a week of getting the mice used to the equipment first. The vibration group received 20 minutes daily of vibration at 32 Hz with 0.5g acceleration. The runners logged 45 minutes daily on treadmills set at 10 meters per minute with a slight uphill grade. All sessions happened during the mice’s active hours (their night time). Throughout the study, the researchers weighed the mice weekly and ran tests to check their metabolism, including how they handled sugar loads and responded to insulin. Blood tests measured insulin, osteocalcin (a bone hormone), and various fats. After the 12 weeks, the researchers examined tissues including muscle, fat, liver, and bone using techniques like microscopic analysis, CT scanning, and mechanical testing to see how the different treatments affected the body at the tissue level.

Results

The treadmill runners and the vibration group both showed improvements compared to the sedentary diabetic mice. While all db/db mice remained heavier than normal mice, the treated groups lost a bit of weight. Both treatments prevented muscle wasting in diabetic mice, returning their muscle fibers to sizes matching healthy mice. When examining fat, both treatments shrank fat cells, but only in the metabolically dangerous belly fat around organs, not in the fat just under the skin. For blood sugar management—crucial for diabetes—both treatments helped. The runners showed better ability to clear glucose during testing, while both groups improved insulin sensitivity and reduced insulin resistance. Both treatments also reduced liver fat in diabetic mice, partially fixing the fatty liver typical in diabetes. For bone health, both treatments increased the bone hormone osteocalcin in diabetic mice, though only traditional exercise increased bone density at the hip. Overall, the vibration treatment matched many, but not all, of exercise’s benefits for metabolism in these diabetic mice.

Limitations

This research, while promising, comes with several important caveats. First, it involved mice, not people, and mouse findings don’t always apply to humans. The db/db mice represent a genetic form of diabetes, whereas most human cases develop from a mix of genes and lifestyle. The 12-week timeline is short compared to human diabetes, which develops over years. The researchers used specific vibration settings (32 Hz, 0.5g) that may differ from commercial vibration platforms. While both treatments improved many aspects of metabolism, they didn’t completely fix everything—blood fats remained abnormal, and some liver markers stayed concerning. Finally, the researchers identified increased osteocalcin levels with treatment but couldn’t say for sure whether this hormone directly caused the metabolic improvements.

Discussion and Takeaways

The main takeaway is that mechanical stimulation through vibration might help people who can’t do regular exercise. This matters for folks with mobility problems, severe obesity, or other conditions that make typical workouts tough. The study adds to emerging science showing that physical forces affect metabolism through complex body-wide signals, possibly involving bone hormones like osteocalcin. The researchers describe vibration as potentially mimicking some effects of exercise without the same exertion, though they stress that regular exercise remains ideal when possible. The findings open new research paths: What vibration settings work best? Do the benefits last? How exactly does the body convert vibration into metabolic changes? Human trials will need to test these findings and determine if vibration therapy could work alongside diet, medication, and traditional exercise in diabetes care.

Funding and Disclosures

The research received support from several reputable sources: an internal grant from the Medical College of Georgia (Child Health Discovery Institute), National Institutes of Health Grants NIDDK K01-DK100616 and NIA P01-AG036675-01, an American Diabetes Association Grant 1-16-JDF-062, and the National Institute on Aging Intramural Research Program. The authors declared no conflicts of interest, stating they had “nothing to disclose.” This transparent funding information helps establish the work’s scientific integrity, showing support from established research institutions and agencies focused on advancing medical knowledge and public health.

Publication Information

This study, “Whole-Body Vibration Mimics the Metabolic Effects of Exercise in Male Leptin Receptor–Deficient Mice,” appeared in the peer-reviewed journal Endocrinology in May 2017 (Volume 158, Issue 5, pages 1160-1171). Meghan E. McGee-Lawrence from Augusta University’s Department of Cellular Biology and Anatomy led the research, with collaborators from various departments including Orthopedic Surgery, Pediatrics, Physiology, Oral Biology, Neuroscience and Regenerative Medicine, plus researchers from the National Institute on Aging. The paper can be found online with the identifier DOI: 10.1210/en.2016-1250 for those wanting to read the original research.

This article is an update to a version first published on March 19, 2017.

Highlighted Articles

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Stay Connected

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.